How had she found him?
His penthouse occupied the top three floors of Sullivan Tower, accessible only by private elevator.
Carter swept through the doors and laid Natalie on his bed with excruciating care, arranging pillows beneath her head, smoothing her hair back from her face.
“Dr. Reynolds is five minutes out,” Marcus reported from the doorway. “What do you need?”
“Water. Food. Something gentle. Broth, crackers, whatever,” Carter said tightly. “And find out how long she was standing outside my building. I want security footage. I want to know when she arrived and why no one let her in.”
His voice had gone deadly quiet, which his employees knew was far more dangerous than yelling.
“Right away, sir.”
Carter sank into the chair beside the bed, unable to look away from her.
God, she was beautiful. Even pale and exhausted, with dark circles under her eyes like bruises, she was the most beautiful thing he’d ever seen.
He’d thought about her every day—every single day—since she’d disappeared from his life like smoke.
The way she’d laughed at his terrible jokes. The way she’d looked at him like he was more than just his bank account or his last name. The way she’d felt in his arms, soft and warm and perfect.
It had terrified him.
That night with her had been… everything. He’d never felt anything like it. The connection had been instant and overwhelming, like coming home to a place he’d never been.
He’d never been so present with another person. Never felt so seen.
And then his father had called, voice weak and fading, saying this was it, come now, and Carter had thrown on his clothes with shaking hands and run.
He’d meant to come back. He’d intended to return to that hotel room, to the woman who’d looked at him like he was a miracle, to figure out what in the world this thing between them was.
But his father had died at 4:47 a.m., and in the chaos and grief that followed—planning a funeral, managing his father’s estate, suddenly becoming responsible for two traumatized teenagers and a company worth billions—time had blurred.
He’d gotten back to the hotel three days later, only to find she’d checked out.
No forwarding address. No contact information. Nothing.
The private investigators had hit wall after wall. The charity gala’s guest list had been extensive. “Natalie” alone had yielded seventeen possibilities, none of whom matched her description.
The friend she’d mentioned—Charlotte something—had proven equally elusive.
It was like she’d never existed at all.
He’d started to wonder if he’d imagined her. If grief and exhaustion had conjured a perfect woman with kind eyes and a laugh that made his chest ache.
Maybe she’d been too good to be true.
But she was here now. Real and solid and in his bed.
Why?
Dr. Reynolds arrived with his usual efficiency, examining Natalie with practiced hands while Carter hovered like an anxious ghost.
“Dehydration,” the doctor announced. “Exhaustion. When’s the last time she ate?”
“I don’t know,” Carter admitted.
“She needs fluids, rest, and food. In that order,” the doctor said. “I’m setting up an IV. She should wake within the hour.”
He glanced at Carter. “Any idea what caused this?”
“No,” Carter said, jaw clenching. “But I’m going to find out.”
True to prediction, Natalie’s eyes fluttered open forty‑seven minutes later.
Carter was still in the chair beside the bed, unable to move, watching the steady rise and fall of her chest like it was the only thing tethering him to Earth.
Her gaze found him immediately, and even confused and disoriented, the recognition in her eyes hit him like a punch to the solar plexus.
She knew him.
She’d come looking for him specifically.
“Where…?” Her voice came out scratchy.
“My apartment,” he said. “You collapsed outside Sullivan Tower.”
He wanted to touch her so badly his hands ached.
“What were you doing outside my building?”
She blinked, processing, and then something shifted in her expression. Fear. Determination. Resignation. All tangled together.
She pushed herself up on shaky arms, and Carter immediately moved to help, adjusting the pillows behind her.
She looked at him for a long moment. Those eyes—God, those eyes that had haunted his dreams—were full of something he couldn’t read.
And then she said it. Blurted it out like ripping off a bandage.
“I’m pregnant,” she whispered. “It’s yours. I spent all day waiting to tell you.”
The room tilted.
Carter heard the words, understood them individually, but together they formed a sentence his brain couldn’t quite process.
Pregnant.
Yours.
All day waiting.
His mind spun through possibilities, implications, every emotion at once until it all blurred into white noise.
She was pregnant with his child.
His immediate instinct was joy. Pure, uncomplicated joy that crashed through him like a wave.
He was going to be a father.
Natalie was here, carrying his baby, and everything in him wanted to pull her close and never let go.
But then another feeling rose up. Cold. Familiar.
Doubt.
Three years ago, a woman named Vanessa Hartley had shown up at his office with ultrasound photos and tears and a story about being pregnant with his child.
He’d believed her. Supported her. Started planning a future.
Until the pregnancy had ended at a very convenient time and it came out that there had never been a pregnancy at all—just forged medical documents and a woman who’d been paid by a rival company to destroy his reputation and distract him during a crucial merger.
The scandal had been brutal. The betrayal had been worse.
Carter looked at Natalie—sweet, kind Natalie, who’d disappeared for two months without a trace—and hated himself for what he was thinking.
But he’d been fooled before, lied to before, and he had two siblings depending on him now, a company to protect, a legacy to preserve.
“Why didn’t you contact me before today?” The words came out harder than he intended.
Something flickered in her eyes. Hurt.
“I tried,” she said hoarsely. “Today. Your receptionist wouldn’t let me in. She said you don’t see anyone without appointments.”
“So you waited outside all day without food or water?” The anger in his voice surprised him—at her, at the situation, at himself. He wasn’t sure.
“I didn’t know how else to reach you,” she said, lifting her chin. “You didn’t leave a number when you ran out that night.”
The accusation stung because it was fair.
“My father was dying,” he said quietly.
“I know that now. I didn’t know it then,” she replied, her hands clasped in her lap, knuckles white. “I’m not here to blame you or ask for anything. You just… you deserve to know. That’s all.”
Carter stood, needing to move, needing to think. His mind was racing through logistics, possibilities, outcomes.
“How far along?”
“Eight weeks,” she answered.
The timeline matched their night together.
But timelines could be manipulated. He’d learned that the hard way.
God, he hated himself. Hated the cold calculation creeping into his thoughts when all he wanted was to trust her, to believe her, to pull her into his arms and tell her everything would be okay.
But people had tried to destroy him before, and they’d use any weapon.
“I want a paternity test,” he said finally.
The words dropped into the room like stones.
The silence that followed stretched so long that Natalie wondered if she’d actually heard him correctly. Maybe her exhausted brain had scrambled the words. Maybe he’d said something else entirely.
But no—the look on his face, distant and controlled, told her she’d heard exactly right.
“A paternity test,” she repeated, her voice flat.
“Yes.”
Something inside her cracked. Not broke—breaking would come later. This was just the first hairline fracture in what would eventually become a complete shattering.
“Of course,” she said. She was proud of how steady her voice sounded. “I expected that.”
It was a lie. She hadn’t expected it at all.
In her naive, foolish heart, she’d imagined… what? That he’d be happy? That he’d pull her close and kiss her and tell her everything would be okay? That the man who’d held her so tenderly, who’d whispered soft words in the dark, who’d looked at her like she was precious, would believe her?
Stupid. So incredibly stupid.
“I’ll arrange for the test tomorrow,” Carter said, and was it her imagination or did he sound relieved, like he’d been bracing for an argument? “Dr. Reynolds can handle it discreetly.”
“Fine.” Natalie swung her legs over the side of the bed, ignoring how the room tilted slightly. The IV was still in her arm, but she didn’t care. She needed to leave.
“I’ll go now.”
“You’re not going anywhere.” Carter’s hand shot out, catching her wrist—not hard, but firm enough to stop her. “You collapsed. You’re dehydrated. You haven’t eaten.”
“I’m fine.”
“You’re not fine,” he said. “You’re pregnant, and you spent all day in the sun without food or water. That’s not fine.”
“Why do you care?” The words burst out before she could stop them. “You don’t even believe it’s yours. You think I’m lying, so why does it matter?”
Something flashed in his eyes—pain maybe, or guilt—but it was gone before she could be sure.
“Because if you are pregnant, if that baby is mine, then you’re both my responsibility,” he said quietly. “And I take care of what’s mine.”
The possessiveness in his tone should have annoyed her, should have made her bristle, but instead it did something complicated to her chest, made her heart do a stupid little flip she didn’t have time for.
“I’m not yours,” she said softly. “The baby might be.”
“Might be,” he echoed.
She laughed, and it sounded broken. “Right. Of course.”
Carter’s phone buzzed. He glanced at it, frowned, then looked back at her.
“I need to make a call,” he said. “Stay here. Eat something. There’s food coming up.”
“I’m not hungry.”
“I don’t care. You need to eat.” He was already heading toward the door. “Don’t leave this apartment, Natalie. I mean it.”
And then he was gone, leaving her alone in his massive bedroom with its floor‑to‑ceiling windows overlooking New York City and its enormous bed that probably cost more than her yearly rent.
Natalie looked down at her hands. They were shaking.
What had she expected? Really, truly, what had she expected when she decided to come here today?
Carter Sullivan was a billionaire. A man who lived in a different stratosphere entirely. The fact that they’d shared one magical night didn’t change the fundamental reality of their situations.
He was powerful and wealthy and surrounded by people who wanted things from him.
Of course he’d be suspicious. Of course he’d want proof.
But it still hurt.
It hurt so much more than she’d thought possible.
A knock at the door made her jump.
A man in a white chef’s coat entered with a tray.
“Soup, crackers, fruit, water,” he said kindly. He set it on the nightstand. “Mr. Sullivan insisted you eat, miss. The soup is gentle on the stomach. And there’s ginger tea for nausea.”
“Thank you,” Natalie managed.
When he left, she stared at the food. Her stomach growled despite everything.
When was the last time she’d eaten? Yesterday morning? She couldn’t remember.
The anxiety about coming here had stolen her appetite completely.
The soup was delicious—some kind of vegetable broth with soft noodles. She ate slowly, mechanically, and tried not to think about Carter’s expression when she’d told him about the pregnancy.
That flash of joy she’d seen before the shutters came down.
She hadn’t imagined that. She was sure she hadn’t.
He’d been happy. For maybe three seconds.
Then the doubt had crept in.
What had happened to him to make him so mistrustful?
In his study, Carter listened to Marcus’s report with mounting fury that had nowhere to go but inward.
“Security footage shows she arrived at 8:42 a.m., sir,” Marcus said. “She approached the front desk at 8:45. Ms. Chen spoke with her for approximately ninety seconds before escorting her out. The subject then positioned herself across the street and remained there for the next nine hours and sixteen minutes.”
“Nine hours,” Carter repeated, voice dangerously quiet. “She stood outside my building for nine hours without food, without water. Pregnant.”
“It appears so, sir.”
“And Margaret Chen turned her away.”
“According to the footage, yes. Ms. Chen appeared to be… dismissive.”
“Dismissive.” Carter replayed the footage on his laptop, watching Natalie approach the desk with her shoulders squared despite obvious nervousness. Watching Margaret’s face transform into something cold and cruel. Watching Natalie’s expression crumble.
Watching her stand outside his building for hours in the summer heat, swaying on her feet, pressing her hand against the wall for support.
All because she wanted to tell him he was going to be a father.
The guilt was a living thing, clawing at his insides.
She’d told him the truth about trying to reach him. About being turned away. About waiting all day.
But that didn’t mean she was telling the truth about everything else.
God, he hated this. Hated the suspicion that had become second nature. Hated that he couldn’t just trust her.
“Find out everything about Margaret Chen,” he said. “Why she turned Natalie away. Whether there was any communication beforehand. Anything suspicious.”
“Already on it, sir,” Marcus replied.
He hesitated. “And about Ms. Spencer… the investigation you requested. The preliminary report should be ready by morning.”
Right. The investigation.
Carter had sent Natalie’s first name and the little he knew about her to his private investigator the moment he’d recognized her unconscious on the sidewalk, before he’d even known about the pregnancy. Just a gut instinct to know everything about the woman who’d haunted him for two months.
Now it felt dirty. Invasive. Like a betrayal.
Necessary, the cold part of his brain insisted.
You need to know who she really is.
“Send it when it’s ready,” he said, and hated himself a little more.
When he returned to the bedroom, Natalie had finished eating. She was standing by the window, arms wrapped around herself, staring out at the city lights.
She looked small.
Fragile.
Beautiful.
“Better?” he asked quietly.
She didn’t turn around. “Thank you for the food.”
“You should rest,” he said. “The guest room is made up. Or… you can stay here. I’ll take the couch.”
“I should go home.”
“Not tonight.” Carter moved closer, unable to help himself. “It’s late. You’re exhausted. Please just stay. One night.”
She finally turned to look at him, and the expression on her face gutted him.
It wasn’t anger. It wasn’t even hurt.
It was resignation.
Like she’d expected disappointment and he’d delivered exactly that.
“One night,” she agreed quietly. “But then I’m leaving.”
“We’ll talk about that tomorrow.”
“There’s nothing to talk about,” she said. “You’ll do your test, get your results, and then—” She shrugged. “Then you’ll either believe me or you won’t.”
“Natalie—”
“I’m tired, Carter. Can you just show me where I’m sleeping?”
He wanted to argue. Wanted to explain about Vanessa, about the betrayal, about why he was this way.
But the exhaustion in her eyes stopped him.
“This way,” he said instead.
The guest room was down the hall, spacious and elegant, with its own bathroom and a bed that looked like a cloud.
Natalie walked in without a word, and Carter found himself hovering in the doorway like an idiot.
“If you need anything…”
“I’ll be fine,” she said. “There are clothes in the closet?”
“My assistant keeps the guest room stocked.”
“Okay.”
“And if you get hungry again, the kitchen—”
“Carter.” She finally looked at him. Really looked at him. “I’m not going to rob you in the middle of the night. I’m not going to trash your apartment or steal your valuables or whatever you’re worried about. I’m just going to sleep. That’s all.”
The accusation stung because it was fair.
“That’s not what I’m worried about,” he said.
“Then what are you worried about?”
You, he wanted to say. I’m worried about you. About how pale you look. About how you stood outside my building for nine hours because you had no other way to reach me. About how badly I want to believe you, and how terrified I am to do it.
What came out instead was, “Just… rest well.”
And then he closed the door before he could do something reckless like beg her to believe he wasn’t the monster he was acting like.
In the hallway, Carter leaned against the wall and tried to breathe.
She was here.
Under his roof.
Possibly carrying his child.
After two months of searching, of wondering, she’d walked right up to his building, and he’d had her turned away.
His phone buzzed with an email: the preliminary report from his investigator.
Carter stared at it for a long moment before opening it—and hated himself just a little more.
PART TWO – TRUST, DOUBT, AND A HEARTBEAT
Natalie woke at 3:00 a.m. with her stomach staging a full‑scale rebellion.
She barely made it to the bathroom before losing the meager dinner she’d managed to keep down.
Morning sickness, she’d discovered, was a cruel misnomer. It struck whenever it wanted to, with a viciousness that left her weak and shaking.
She was crouched on the cool marble floor, forehead pressed against her arm, when she heard the knock.
“Natalie? Are you okay?” Carter’s voice.
Of course. Because apparently this situation wasn’t humiliating enough already.
“I’m fine,” she croaked. “Go away.”
The door opened anyway—because apparently “go away” translated to “please come watch this” in billionaire.
“I said I’m—” She looked up, intending to unleash every ounce of irritation she had left and stopped.
Carter was standing in the doorway in soft pajama pants, hair disheveled, eyes worried.
He was holding a mug.
“Is that… ginger tea?” she asked weakly.
“How did you know?” he said, coming in to set it on the counter.
“Because I practically live on it now,” she muttered.
He wetted a washcloth, kneeling beside her to press it gently against her forehead.
The gesture was so gentle, so unexpected, that Natalie felt tears prick her eyes, which was ridiculous. She was not going to cry over a washcloth.
“I’m a mess,” she muttered instead.
“You’re pregnant,” he countered. “There’s a difference.”
“Same result,” she said. “Messiness.”
The corner of his mouth twitched, almost a smile.
“Drink the tea,” he urged. “It helps.”
She sipped it carefully, the warmth spreading through her chest.
“You keep ginger tea on hand for your pregnant guests?” she asked.
Leave a Comment